Home Eco News Eco News / Issue 87 July 2011 Collaring or Culling: The Fraser Island Dingo
Collaring or Culling: The Fraser Island Dingo

Save Fraser Island Dingoes Inc

dingoThe Dingo is protected in Queensland National Parks as a native species, (Nature Conservation Act 1992,) and the State Government has a legal responsibility to conserve these populations and an obligation to ensure that the management of the dingo is ethical and humane.

The latest project by Qld. National Parks (DERM) is to attach tracking collars to 20 dingoes in the hope of monitoring the animals movements over the Island.

Whilst research is needed scientist's question the ethics of using such an invasive device and dingo experts believe these collars will be even more detrimental than the ear tags.

It is widely considered by animal behaviourist's and the scientific community that no surveillance method should be used which is likely to interfere with the animals' ability to function naturally, but these tracking collars will disrupt normal dingo behaviour, some animals may be ostracized or even killed by other members of the pack, the collars will also interfere with normal foraging and hunting, so how will the data collected be deemed to be accurate?

Tourists and local residents are appalled on seeing these cumbersome collars and there are many doubts as to veracity of this methodology, we ask the Minister Ms. Kate Jones and Qld National Parks (DERM) the following questions..

What ethics/approvals have been obtained and from where?

What studies have been done to ensure these devices will not interfere with natural behaviours such as hunting, whelping, feeding pups and interacting with other pack members?

What University staff are involved and what are the credentials of those involved in this study?

Sub-adults are mentioned, what is the actual age of the animals collared?

What is the purpose of locating dens? In the past den identification has not prevented the areas from being burnt out.

There is some confusion as to how the release mechanism functions. How will those monitoring know when an animal is entangled, unable to hunt or care for pups? Especially since the rangers leave the Island in the evening.

What is the explicit purpose of this research and what is hoped to be achieved?

If the results indicate the dingoes are in crisis, what will be your response?

How do you reconcile the use of these collars with your policy of regarded dingoes as "wild, native animals that should be interfered with as little as possible" and of "conserving the species in a near-natural environment."?

This study is inhumane and obviously inhibits the natural behaviours of the animals, the collars should be removed, the project suspended forthwith and a more ethical method of research examined...

dingo-collar

Share
 

Comments  

 
0 #1 2011-07-05 00:31
From someone who has been involved in the radio tracking of many animal species, often with radio collars, & working with dingoes, I am acutely aware of the strict ethical approvals needed from the relevant licensing/scientific body before such research can commence. Therefore, most of these questions could be answered by simply asking for the ethics approval.

In my experience, the presence of collars rarely impacts upon the individuals & is far less intrusive than other methods such as visually tracking & capturing. What methods are you proposing? This article seems to miss the point of what appears to be the goal of the study: learn more about the dingo's behaviour & habits so that they can be better managed into the future.

Rather than taking juvenile potshots in the public media, get on board & ask how you can assist in improving the knowledge of a population that interacts with humans like no other, & ensure that they are best protected into the future.
 
 
+4 #2 2011-07-05 05:22
First of all, I question the "need" for such research. Secondly, since 1990 the Queensland Government have refused to listen to any views on FI dingo management other than their own. "Getting on board" with the Queensland Government means that you must agree with them, or go away, as many people over the last 20 years or so have found out. Its been said before, but I'll say it again, the FI Dingo Mangement Plan is the worst wildlife management blunder ever committed in Queensland.
 
 
+4 #3 2011-07-05 06:17
If you can believe a collar like the one shown in the picture does not have any affect on the animal’s behaviour, you do have limited knowledge on this subject.
How much restriction does a wide collar have in stopping the dingo’s neck rotating to its fullest extent especially when trying to capture its prey?
The size of the tracking device reflects the lack of compassion by the researchers in gathering this data. Do these collars need to be so large, when you have children going to school with GPS enabled mobile phones small enough to fit into the palm of their tiny hands.
I think we are not focusing on the real issue here, which is that the collection of data is just a furphy, the government wants to cull the dingo on Fraser Island, all it needs is some figures it can manipulate to achieve their desired outcome.
DW
 
 
+3 #4 2011-07-07 03:08
These cumbersome devices would most definitely have a negative impact on the dingoes. I would like to see those who decided upon this device, wear one on their necks 24/7 for as many months as these poor animals have to, and then see whether they could say it did not impair their natural movements in any way. Why is it so difficult to realize that as a predator, dingoes must be able to utilize ALL their natural instincts and movements to be able to survive? What hypocrisy that on the one hand DERM insists that the dingoes should not be interfered with by humans, yet it is okay for THEM to interfere with these unfortunate collared animals. Since when does DERM care about the survival of these dingoes anyway? If democracy really existed in Australia, isn't it time that DERM listened to what the people say? We may just know more than what they do about animals!
 
 
-1 #5 2011-07-07 03:12
These cumbersome devices would most definitely have a negative impact on the dingoes. I would like to see those who decided upon this device, wear one on their necks 24/7 for as many months as these poor animals have to, and then see whether they could say it did not impair their natural movements in any way. Why is it so difficult to realize that as a predator, dingoes must be able to utilize ALL their natural instincts and movements to be able to survive? What hypocrisy that on the one hand DERM insists that the dingoes should not be interfered with by humans, yet it is okay for THEM to interfere with these unfortunate collared animals. Since when does DERM care about the survival of these dingoes anyway? If democracy really existed in Australia, isn't it time that DERM listened to what the people say? We may just know more than what they do about animals!
 
 
+3 #6 2011-07-08 04:12
The terrible plight of the Fraser Island Dingoes is known to all who care about their welfare. The late Lionel Hudson in his book "Dingoes Don't Bark (they are too busy staying alive) reveals a deep contempt and hatred for dingoes by Aussies, passed on by generation after generation in SA Qld etc Any country that boasts the despicable dingo fence is one which has no understanding of our unique native animals. The colonial mentality with its introduced sheep and cattle, is alive and flourishing across Australia- it is time to be rid of this tainted image and start protecting the Fraser Island Dinoes. Right now is a good tiejm to start. NOW
.
 
 
+1 #7 2011-07-08 04:12
The terrible plight of the Fraser Island Dingoes is known to all who care about their welfare. The late Lionel Hudson in his book "Dingoes Don't Bark (they are too busy staying alive) reveals a deep contempt and hatred for dingoes by Aussies, passed on by generation after generation in SA Qld etc Any country that boasts the despicable dingo fence is one which has no understanding of our unique native animals. The colonial mentality with its introduced sheep and cattle, is alive and flourishing across Australia- it is time to be rid of this tainted image and start protecting the Fraser Island Dinoes. Right now is a good tiejm to start. NOW
.
 
 
0 #8 2011-11-08 21:41
Are they being tracked so they can be wiped out for the new tent eco resort?
 
facebook twitter feed vimeo